Discovering Key West Islip Beach: A Coastal Culinary Escape
Nestled along the picturesque shores of Long Island, Key West Islip Beach offers more than just a stunning view; it presents a genuine taste of island life right here in Islip, New York. Located strategically at 600 S Bay Ave, this establishment has carved out a unique niche for itself, blending the relaxed, vibrant atmosphere of the Florida Keys with the familiar warmth of a local favorite. It serves as a perfect destination for those seeking an authentic waterfront dining experience, whether you are a lifelong resident of Long Island or just passing through this charming coastal town. The location itself is a significant draw, providing diners with immediate access to the serene beauty of the bay, making every meal feel like a mini-vacation.
The essence of Key West Islip Beach lies in its commitment to fresh, high-quality ingredients served in an environment that encourages relaxation and enjoyment. It’s a place where the sound of the water complements the clinking of glasses, and the menu reflects a thoughtful curation of coastal favorites. Forget the hustle and bustle of everyday life; stepping into this venue means embracing a slower pace, one dictated by the tides and the setting sun. This dedication to atmosphere, combined with culinary execution, is what sets it apart in the competitive New York dining scene.
The restaurant’s appeal is multifaceted, catering to various dining preferences while maintaining a consistent standard of excellence. It’s a spot renowned for its ability to transition seamlessly from a casual lunch spot enjoyed after a day by the water to an inviting evening venue perfect for savoring sunset views over dinner. The commitment to creating a memorable experience, rooted deeply in its seaside location, is evident in every detail, from the welcoming service to the thoughtfully designed space that maximizes the stunning natural surroundings.
Key Highlights of the Key West Islip Beach Experience
To truly understand the allure of Key West Islip Beach, one must appreciate the core elements that define its identity. These distinguishing features contribute significantly to its reputation as a premier coastal dining destination:
Prime Waterfront Location: The address at 600 S Bay Ave places the restaurant directly on the water, offering unparalleled views of the bay. This setting is crucial, providing a backdrop that enhances every dish and conversation. Diners frequently cite the scenic beauty as a primary reason for repeat visits, especially during the warmer months when outdoor seating is at its peak.
Coastal-Inspired Menu Philosophy: While the specific offerings evolve with the seasons, the underlying theme remains strongly connected to fresh, flavorful coastal cuisine. The culinary approach emphasizes simplicity and quality, allowing the natural taste of fresh seafood and complementary ingredients to shine through. This focus ensures a dining experience that feels both indulgent and genuine to its location.
Vibrant, Relaxed Ambiance: The atmosphere successfully captures the laid-back, carefree spirit associated with the Florida Keys, transplanted perfectly onto Long Island. It fosters an environment where guests feel comfortable lingering over their meals, enjoying the sea breeze and the convivial energy of the space. It strikes a perfect balance between casual accessibility and an elevated dining feel.
Community Hub Status: More than just a place to eat, Key West Islip Beach functions as a genuine gathering spot for the local community. It’s where friends meet, families celebrate, and visitors discover the best of Islip’s shoreline culture. This deep integration into the local fabric adds an authentic layer of warmth and familiarity to the overall experience.
Embracing the Island Vibe in Islip
Key West Islip Beach is more than just its physical location or its menu; it represents a lifestyle choice—a conscious decision to slow down and appreciate the finer, simpler pleasures of life by the water. The team behind the establishment understands that exceptional dining is a synergy of excellent food, attentive service, and an unforgettable setting. They have meticulously cultivated an environment where the stresses of the mainland seem miles away, replaced instead by the soothing rhythm of the bay.
For anyone exploring the South Shore of Long Island, seeking a destination that promises both culinary satisfaction and scenic beauty, a visit to 600 S Bay Ave is highly recommended. It stands as a testament to how a well-executed concept, deeply rooted in its geographical context, can create a truly unique and enduring dining landmark. Whether you are looking for a casual bite or a special occasion setting, Key West Islip Beach offers an authentic slice of coastal paradise waiting to be explored.
Amenities and More
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
From the business
Identifies as women-owned
Service options
Outdoor seating
Delivery
Takeaway
Dine-in
Highlights
Fast service
Great beer selection
Great cocktails
Live music
Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining
Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Cocktails
Coffee
Comfort food
Happy-hour drinks
Quick bite
Small plates
Spirits
Vegetarian options
Wine
Dining options
Breakfast
Lunch
Dinner
Dessert
Seating
Table service
Amenities
Bar on site
Toilet
Atmosphere
Casual
Cosy
Crowd
Groups
Tourists
Planning
Accepts reservations
Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards
Children
Good for kids
High chairs
Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot
On-site parking
Plenty of parking
Pets
Dogs allowed
Menus
Appetizers
Lobster BisqueUS$11.00
Classic Onion SoupUS$9.00
Salads
Latitudes' Caesar SaladUS$12.00
Frisee & Artisan Greens SaladUS$12.00
Sandwiches
Latitudes' BurgerUS$18.00
Surf & Turf BurgerUS$32.00
Grouper SandwichUS$26.00
Entrees
Pan Roasted ChickenUS$32.00
Seared GrouperUS$46.00
Pan Roasted Rosemary CobiaUS$42.00
Photos
Reviews Key West Islip Beach
J ProShots
19-12-2025
You need to be a town resident during summer season. Love this place and the restaurant KEY WEST they have some refreshing drinks and some tasty food. They have grill on the other side so you can BBQ and the beach is right there don’t need to walk miles to jump in the water
Service
Dine in
Lisa Ungar
16-12-2025
I have eaten here before, I work nearby. The food has always been good and the view of the bay is beautiful. I took my daughters here for the first time as we were looking for a casual place with good seafood. After what happened with my daughter though, I was very disappointed. She ordered the grilled Mahi-mahi with vegetables for $25. She was given the wrong order of a fried fish sandwich with French fries. (She doesn’t eat fried food). They offered to bring vegetables but for an extra $5. The sandwich they brought was about $17-18 on the menu which they acknowledged they overcharged her, but did not offer to fix the mistake or offer a refund. As much as I enjoy the food and the vibe here, the customer service is lacking. My food was good, but did not enjoy it because the whole experience. I would hope that the wait staff gets better training in customer service.
Price per person
$20–30
Food: 3
Service: 1
Atmosphere: 4
Noise level
Moderate noise
Group size
3-4 people
Wait time
No wait
Recommendation for vegetarians
Not sure
Parking space
Somewhat difficult to find parking
Parking options
Paid parking lot
Wheelchair accessibility
There is a ramp
Bryan Webb
15-12-2025
Great hidden spot right on the beach. Perfect place to grab a breakfast sandwich or omelet to enjoy by the water. Or stay for lunch and try the baked crab while enjoyed a beer.
EXP Smith
14-12-2025
Great place, hidden Gem...great Sunset 🌅 and great Pizza 🍕 Sal is a gentleman.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Neil A Rosenberg
21-11-2025
A hidden gem of a small Beach spot with food concession.
Meal type
Lunch
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 4
Noise level
Quiet, easy to talk
Group size
1 person, 2 people, 3-4 people, 5-8 people
Wait time
No wait
Gleb Beleavski
18-11-2025
Good food. Great location and great live music
Price per person
$30–50…
More
John Halter
14-11-2025
Cool little dining spot at Islip town beach right by The Great South Bay. Decent food menu with simple sandwiches and that type of fare. Decent beer selection here with a couple craft options. Live music sometimes as well. Playground and beach for the kids to keep busy. More
Zylo
11-11-2025
Quaint little spot of beach. Doesn't compare to Robert Moses or Jones beaches, but for locality and convenience it's very nice.
Carl Campagna
07-11-2025
A hidden gem! Went for breakfast, the food was good. Met the owner Sal, what a nice guy and a very friendly staff. We are going back for dinner and live music. More
William Hyer
05-11-2025
[I am re-writing this review because my editing skills are sub-par when falling asleep with my finger hitting the delete button. Hence, the entire review was lost, but not all of the pictures.] … More
Wendy S. Delmater Thies
25-10-2025
A really fun place down by the Islip Bay Beach. Your order at a booth and then give you your your drink, and then you have the food delivered to your table. Very, very casual, people wearing everything from jeans and t-shirts to swimsuits. … More
Alice Steck
16-10-2025
Fab summer outdoor beach dining located at Islip Beach. It has menu items one would never expect at a beach venue. Alcohol by the pitcher avaliable More
Nicole A
02-10-2025
🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
Absolutely loved this beachfront gem! The view was stunning, the breeze was perfect, and the lobster roll was fresh and full of flavor—definitely one of the best I’ve had. The servers were so kind and welcoming, making the whole experience even better. Can’t wait to come bac
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
mark aston
07-09-2025
Amazing place right on the beach with decent food and brilliant service. Owner and staff were so welcoming and made us feel valued customers. Worth a visit. More
Madeline the Great!!
01-08-2025
Where else can you have waterfront dining at a reasonable price, AND have live music??
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Jessica Lentz
18-07-2025
I have taken my prom pictures, got married here, take my daughter to the beach here every summer, the new showers and food hut is amazing. Nice and small. Its perfect. Also they have two nice playgrounds for the kids.
Liliana Alvarado
14-07-2025
Quiet little beach, mostly for sitting, catching the sun or having nice dinner by the sea on the restaurant. I wouldn't go in the water but there is a lifeguard , so you can go in
Madeline the Great!!
09-07-2025
Where else can you have waterfront dining at a reasonable price, AND have live music??
Food: 5…
More
Ahmad Ali
13-06-2025
They have amazing music there on Monday nights
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Bob Coletti
21-05-2025
Karaoke on Tuesday nights Tons of fun
Sorry it's over for the summer.. very pleasant wait staff and others. We were there with 20 neighbors and all of us had a ball. More
William Purdy
21-05-2025
Live music, beautiful sunsets, great seafood, great drinks...need I say more? The owner Sal walks around during the weekends and ensures food and ambiance is to everyone’s satisfaction. He recommended the baked crabs which we loved over … More
E Perera
10-05-2025
Never ate there, need to try one day the atmosphere and the view of the bay is dynamite.
Atmosphere:…
More
Mary Yashowitz
27-04-2025
West there this past weekend. Very good bar food. Good lobster roll, baked crab (amazing). Drinks very good! Nice atmosphere and very good live music after 6:00 pm. Very friendly, casual place! More
Sandy L
31-03-2025
A great local getaway! A weekend visit or on your weekday lunch break... drive down, eat your lunch while enjoying the cool breeze and pretty waves. Bring the kids to enjoy the playground area. Cute Tiki Bar/Restaurant, Outdoor Deck, Outdoor Showers and Plenty of Seating, Tables, Benches and Gazebo for a shady retreat. Stop by and take a look if you're in the Islip area, just off downtown Main Street, South all the way to the end.
Food: 4
Service: 4
Atmosphere: 5
Parking options
Free parking lot
Joe Yen
31-03-2025
It is close to Key West feel as you can in Long Island. Nice set up with plenty outdoor seating, music. Has clean bathroom and outdoor shower. Next to the beach, the food is good and not over priced. Other than the rocky sands and brown color ocean you would really think you are in key west...Can't fix long island beaches..,😀
Meal type
Brunch
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 4
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 4
Cynthia Indelicato
25-03-2025
Everyone from the staff to patrons, were friendly and courteous. The food was delicious and affordable. I’m looking forward to returning before the season ends. … More
D. Bell
12-03-2025
We really enjoyed ourselves! The atmosphere was peaceful and of course the day we were there the Sun was shining so you almost got the feeling you were somewhere out in the Caribbean. The food was delicious and the service was outstanding!
Ahmad Ali
04-03-2025
They have amazing music there on Monday nights
Food: 5…
More
Zia Rivera-Clarkson
21-02-2025
Went with a friend on a whim without expectation. Food was great, surprise!!! Vibe was even better!! Delight! Keep playing the reggae and keep the bright colors fresh, I absolutely loved this place. The people who work there were very … More
Michael Warner
19-02-2025
Great place for casual beachside dining and hanging out with friends. Food is well prepared and reasonably priced. My only issue is the live music going on behind my friends and me. Although the two gentlemen are quite talented, the volume impaired conversation at our table. More
Gleb Beleavski
28-01-2025
Good food. Great location and great live music
Price per person
$30–50
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Nina Ungar
26-01-2025
the customer service sucked. if you go here really specify what your ordering I ordered the grilled mahi mahi platter and the cashier(really sweet young girl, but seemed very confused and spacey) rang me up for 25.00 but they gave me a key west sandwich instead which is only 17.00 when I told them they gave me the wrong thing and I can’t eat what they gave me they said they could give me the vegetables for an extra 5.00. After I was already over charged by 8. The girl told me the price difference was only a few dollars stating the sandwich is 22.00 and change. But I looked at one of the signs after everyone was done eating and a big sign that said key west sandwich with a picture of exactly what they gave me said 17 and change. I was with my mother and sister and didnt want to make more of a situation and ruin their vibe but I left hungry and super disappointed the staff did nothing to remedy the situation after I spoke to 3 different people about it I was excited to eat here and the experience was just super disappointing and the staff didn’t seem to care at all about the patrons after complaining they just said I made the wrong order even though I never asked for a sandwich I asked for a mahi mahi grilled plater :/ so yeah 25.00 down and still super hungry not sure what I paid for. I could’ve gotten a really good meal elsewhere. I hardly write reviews unless I really feel wronged. But figured people should know coming here that you might leave without eating your food because the cashier couldn’t get the order right and no one else is willing to do right by a customer that got the wrong order
Price per person
$20–30
Food: 1
Service: 1
Atmosphere: 4
Noise level
Loud, but you can still talk
Group size
3-4 people
Wait time
No wait
Dietary restrictions
If they give you the wrong order and you have dietary restrictions expect that they’ll only change it for you for additional charges
Thomas Kempster
06-01-2025
Great place off the main strip of South Shore. Nice mix of straight barbecue and seafood outside overlooking the bay. Totally awesome with sun going down and Country music performed by Tom Country! Food and service was even better than expected. Definitely a warm weather gem to enjoy!
Price per person
$20–30
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Noise level
Moderate noise
Wait time
No wait
Seating type
Outdoor patio / terrace
Recommendation for vegetarians
Not sure
Parking space
Plenty of parking
Kid-friendliness
Kid friendly
Reviews Key West Islip Beach